8 thoughts on “Crunch

  1. Impressive.
    (That does look like a tree with a shallow root system. Does the more urban environment affect the root depth and strength of trees? Could that sort of planning had any effect on the damage done to the powergrid?)

  2. Whoa! We have several similar trees in our neighborhohod, many fell during the snowstorms, but none are as big as this one!
    These trees remind me of David Wiesner’s picture book Hurricane (as Doug above mentioned).
    Oh, and I’ve been also wondering the same thing as lmc — all these fallen trees seem to have very shallow roots.
    (sorry for the cross-comment citing marathon, I guess I’m in academic mode today).

  3. I’m no aborist, but my understanding is that lots of water=shallow root system. This might be grounds for not watering the trees too much, but if the reason that the tree has lots of water is that it rains a lot and is humid in summer (so the ground doesn’t dry out quickly), then trees will have shallow roots. In the big park near where I live trees fall down every time there’s a storm, and no one waters them at all- they are basically wild, as it’s a wild area of park. If that’s right then there’s not much you can do about the trees having shallow roots in the N.E., as there’s usually plenty of water for them without having to put down deep roots.

  4. Forest ecologist here. All trees have extensive roots near the surface *and* deeper roots. That’s not to say that a tree’s deeper roots can’t weaken because of disease or other stress or break off because of wind. Damage to suburban trees may relate to them being artificially planted in the open and more exposed individually to wind gusts rather than sheltered by neighbors. Or, it’s likely that there is plenty of damage to trees in forests from this weekend’s storm and people just don’t see it or care because those trees didn’t rip through electrical systems and houses. Bottom line: strong winds knock down trees. Always have, always will.
    Also, power companies are probably starting to extensively reinforce wires to limit the danger and liability associated with them snapping in the ever-more frequent ‘worst in a decade’ storms we’ve been experiencing in the last 15-20 years. Yet another cost of climate change that’s being passed along to the customer.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s